Published 17 January 2019
Propensity evidence — harmful digital communications — level of specificity required — whether proposed evidence propensity evidence — Mahomed v R [2011] NZSC 52 — R v Martin [2013] NZCA 486 — Taniwha v R [2016] NZSC 123 — Evidence Act 2006, ss 7, 8, 40(1)(a), 43(3). The defendant faced charges of posting a digital communication (a Facebook post) with the intention to cause harm, and that the posting did cause harm. The Crown sought to have admitted as evidence previous Facebook messages from the defendant to the complainant. The Crown argued that the messages had a tendency to prove the defendant's intention to cause harm to the complainant. The Crown submitted that the messages had a probative value that outweighed the risk of prejudice to the defendant. The defendant submitted that there was distinction between private and public communications and that if it was decided the messages were propensity evidence, the prejudice against the defendant would outweigh any probative value. The court found that the proposed evidence was directly relevant to the defendant's intent and to whether the communication tended to cause harm, and to whether in fact it did cause harm. The messages provided crucial background to the relationship between the defendant and the complainant, and if not allowed to see them the jury would not be able to understand the alleged offending. The court found that the messages were admissible as propensity evidence. Judgment Date: 2 March 2018. * * * Note: names have been changed to comply with legal requirements. * * *
This website explains many of the things you might want to know if you are coming to the Youth Court, or just wondering how the Youth Court works.
Visit website›Ministry of Justice website with information on family issues including about going to court, forms and other times when you may need help.
Visit website›For information about courts and tribunals, including going to court, finding a court & collection of fines and reparation.
Visit website›On this site you will find information about our Supreme Court, Court of Appeal and High Court including recent decisions, daily lists and news.
Visit website›